“That’s the gift that keeps on giving the whole year.” Remember when Eddie shared this memorable quote in Christmas Vacation? Needless to say, he was not talking about feedback. As you know, he was referencing the Jelly of the Month club. As principals, leaders and teachers, we know that Feedback is a GIFT. Feedback is a GIFT that keeps giving the whole year. If you give it. @matthew_arend
This past week feedback has been on my mind. I have been getting ready for my end of year conferences with teachers. During these conferences, feedback will be very important as we lift up and celebrate what has gone well this year, review areas of refinement and set a direction for the next school year. I want to say just the right things, recognizing the efforts of teachers. I also want to provide encouragement and inspiration to keep them learning and growing.
As my week went on, it became more clear, this was a topic I was needing to write about. As I entered into a training session on Thursday, the following image was displayed midway through the morning.
Did this image speak to you like it did to me? I have never underestimated the power of feedback, but I will be honest and tell you my feedback can certainly improve. I am going to use this as a jumping off point to intentionally improve my feedback between now and the end of the year and of course for many years to come.
Regardless of the position you hold, these four statements speak truth into the relationships that exist. George Couros reminds us in the Innovator’s Mindset that it is all about “Relationships, Relationships, Relationships.” Whether you are a leader speaking with teachers or a teacher speaking with students, trusting and authentic relationships must be present for feedback to be effective.
Given with Permission
“In through one ear and out of the other.” I vividly recall being in situations where I was providing feedback and the person who I had wished heard it, was not ready to hear it. Whether they were upset, in denial or just not ready to hear what I had to say, I did not have their permission to share. Before obtaining permission, relationships must be developed, cultivated and nurtured. Trust must be developed so when feedback is sought out or shared, it is given with permission. If someone does not come to you specifically asking for feedback, consider asking someone if you can provide feedback, before you just give it.
Intent is for Growth
Feedback needs to be articulated in a way that moves us forward. As a leader, I need to be mindful of this. I can dwell on what has occurred or I can use what has occurred to guide our next steps. Learning from our past helps us set a clearer path for the future. If success is the ultimate goal, then we must grow.
My reading this week for #IMMOOC including the following statement:
We only get better when we find those who truly elevate us. Look for mentors who will push you to come up with better and brighter ideas and be that person for your followers. Leaders are meant to unleash talent by bringing their people’s strengths to life, not ignoring them.
The above excerpt is an excellent measuring stick for the effectiveness of my feedback. If the feedback I am giving meets what George highlighted above, my intent is for growth. The one nugget that should not be overshadowed is if you are giving feedback, you should have someone providing feedback to you also. Feedback is by no means a one way street. We all need someone to “push us to come up with better and brighter ideas.”
For the Person, Not About the Person
I cannot think of a quicker way to damage the relationships that have been established than making your feedback personal. Recently at a principal’s meeting, we shared feedback with teachers after a brief presentation they shared. Instead of beginning our sentence with the word “you” we were instructed to to specifically state the teachers name. While this seemed bizarre, speaking about someone who was clearly sitting in front of us, it removed the “personal” aspect of the feedback making the feedback more for the person than about the person.
Technology Supports Feedback
I was able to attend a professional learning session this weekend hosted by Alice Keeler. While the focus of much of the morning was on how to best use Google products to enhance learning experiences for students, we also discussed how the same tools could provide feedback to students…instantly. Whether you are using Google products to provide your feedback or using a more traditional face to face model, the graphic below serves as a terrific reminder to provide feedback promptly. Teachers need feedback from peers and leaders in a timely fashion so they can be affirmed of the decisions they are making. Timely feedback also supports teachers in reflecting on decisions should adjustments need to be made. These adjustments may warrant a higher level of success. Feedback for students needs to be timely and shared while student interest is high. While they are giving permission for feedback to be shared. As students seek feedback amidst their engagement, we must follow through. Waiting to respond when it is convenient, tells the student what they are working on is not valued equally, leading to a decrease in their interest, empowerment and engagement. Keeler’s focus on using technology to provide feedback to students also empowers students to give feedback to the teachers. Receiving specific responses, allows for individualized feedback. Just make sure it is for the student and not about the student.
When you ask question to the class and choose one student to respond, you know what one student is thinking. When you ask the question digitally, all students can respond. Instantly.
– Alice Keeler
Targeted for Success
You are on target for success when your feedback is given with permission, the intent is for growth and it is focused for the person and not about the person. The important piece to remember is that feedback is ongoing. As I head into my end of year conferences, I need to be mindful of the fact that success does not happen in one conference. Feedback needs to be on-going and followed up on. Success is a journey. Honestly, there is not a final destination. Just when you feel you have arrived, our best will find another area they want to improve upon. Thus, keeping the need for feedback to be constant and on-going.
As I look to “empower learning, unleash talent, and lead a culture of creativity” as the Innovator’s Mindset calls us to do, I aim to do so through modeling, but also through my feedback to teachers and our teacher’s feedback to our students. Taking risks and attempting to approaching learning with new and better ways can be trepidatious. I need to be sure I am giving the gift that will support the work, lift up teachers and keep them moving forward. I need to remember, feedback is a GIFT.